How To Find Off-Market Properties In New York

How To Find Off-Market Properties In New York: The 4 Best Sources

real estate marketing real estate markets Jan 29, 2024

Unlocking hidden opportunities in the New York real estate market can be a game-changer for savvy investors. Off-market properties, for example, hold immense potential for those seeking unique investments. In this guide, we unveil the strategies and secrets to teach you how to find off-market properties in New York, starting with the following:

Mastering the art of how to find off-market properties in New York is a transformative skill for real estate investors, propelling their careers to new heights. In the competitive landscape of off-market properties in New York, those who have acquired the appropriate knowledge gain a distinct advantage.

Uncovering hidden gems provides investors with exclusive opportunities, enabling them to secure unique deals, negotiate favorable terms, and ultimately build a diversified and lucrative portfolio. This expertise not only unlocks untapped potential but establishes investors as real players in the New York real estate market.

Read Also: How To Flip Houses In New York: Step By Step

*In our video below, Alex Martinez, CEO of Real Estate Skills, shares his experience of purchasing a seven-figure off-market multifamily deal! Alex also provides two reasons why shifting focus to on-market deals can lead to getting off-market properties for wholesaling, house flipping, and even purchasing a rental property.


What Are Off-Market Properties In New York?

Off-market properties New York, often referred to as off-market properties NYC, are real estate assets that are not publicly listed or advertised for sale through traditional channels. These hidden opportunities exist outside the Multiple Listing Service (MLS) and public marketing platforms. Instead, they are discreetly marketed or offered privately, creating a niche market for those who know how to find them.

Additionally, it's essential to recognize that off-market properties in New York extend beyond listings; they also encompass homeowners who haven't officially expressed their intention to sell but may entertain attractive offers. These potential off-market opportunities arise from various scenarios, such as homeowners testing the market discreetly or those contemplating a change but not yet committed to the idea of selling publicly.

The off-market properties New York residents offer are particularly attractive to investors. First and foremost, off-market homes for sale provide a level of exclusivity that can result in more favorable terms for both buyers and sellers. This discretion allows sellers to maintain privacy and avoid the potential drawbacks of public marketing, such as nosy neighbors or market speculation. On the other hand, buyers gain access to properties not readily available to the general public, reducing competition and increasing the likelihood of securing a unique and potentially undervalued asset.

Moreover, understanding how to find off-market properties in New York is crucial for investors seeking to diversify their portfolios. The conventional real estate market often experiences high competition, making it challenging to discover properties with distinctive features or favorable pricing. Off-market opportunities, by virtue of their limited exposure, offer investors the chance to uncover specific amenities that may not conform to mainstream market trends.

Investors should also be aware that many off-market properties come with motivated sellers, whether looking for a quick sale, trying to avoid the costs associated with a public listing, or simply seeking a more discreet transaction. This motivation can translate into negotiation advantages for savvy investors who know how to find off-market properties in New York.

Read Also: How To Find Real Estate Deals: The Top 10 Proven Methods


How To Find Off-Market Properties In New York

find off market properties

Learning how to find off-market properties New York residents want to sell doesn’t need to be difficult. While finding off-market properties differs from finding traditionally listed properties, all investors need to do is adjust their strategies. As a result, we've compiled a list of the best websites for finding off-market properties for sale:

  • Mashvisor
  • Batch Leads
  • ForSaleByOwner.com
  • CityRealty


Mashvisor presents a substantial inventory of off-market listings featuring unique investment opportunities like foreclosures and tenant-occupied properties. With its user-friendly property filters, the platform allows users to tailor their search, streamlining the process of finding properties that align precisely with their investment objectives.

A standout feature of Mashvisor is its cutting-edge investment property calculator, empowering users to effortlessly conduct a thorough analysis of potential investments. This tool delivers precise sales and rental comparisons, detailed ROI (return on investment) and expense analyses, and it’s all presented in an understandable PDF report.

Mashvisor goes beyond posting listings and directly connects with property owners, offering essential information such as phone numbers and emails—this feature streamlines negotiations, allowing users to progress efficiently toward finalizing deals.

In New York’s competitive real estate market, Mashvisor has become an invaluable asset for investors and buyers, providing a comprehensive blend of property data, analytical tools, and direct networking capabilities. It proves to be an essential tool for successfully navigating the off-market property landscape.

Batch Leads

Batch Leads caters to real estate investors in New York seeking off-market properties. Tailored for investors, this comprehensive platform streamlines the identification and management of real estate leads through features like property data filtering, skip tracing, and direct mail marketing.

Offering real-time access to an extensive database, including properties not listed on conventional channels, Batch Leads proves invaluable in New York’s competitive market, enabling users to stay ahead of fellow investors. With targeted marketing capabilities for reaching property owners directly, this platform becomes a crucial asset for securing sought-after off-market deals in the competitive California landscape.

Read Also: Batch Leads Review: Pricing, Features, & Is It Worth It?


ForSaleByOwner.com is a prominent online platform that connects sellers directly with potential buyers, cutting out the middleman and allowing property owners to market their homes independently. This platform becomes a valuable resource for real estate investors in New York looking to find off-market deals because it caters to the growing trend of off-market properties NYC residents want to sell.

The beauty of ForSaleByOwner.com lies in its ability to showcase off-market homes for sale, presenting a unique opportunity for investors who covet under-the-radar deals. By listing their properties directly on the platform, homeowners can discreetly market their homes to a targeted audience, including potential investors eager to uncover off-market properties in New York.

For real estate investors, the allure of ForSaleByOwner.com is twofold. Firstly, it provides a channel for discovering off-market properties in a market as competitive as New York, where exclusive deals can significantly impact investment success. Secondly, the platform facilitates direct communication with property owners, enabling investors to initiate conversations, negotiate terms, and potentially secure off-market deals that may not have been available through traditional channels.

Read Also: What Is FSBO In Real Estate? An Investor's Guide To FSBO Homes


Celebrating three decades as a stalwart in the New York real estate scene, CityRealty.com stands out as a premier resource for investors seeking off-market deals. Renowned for its comprehensive and up-to-date property listings, CityRealty.com caters to the discerning investor's appetite for exclusive opportunities, including off-market properties NYC residents want to sell.

CityRealty.com's enduring presence in the market speaks to its reliability and credibility, making it a go-to platform for anyone buying or selling homes in New York. The platform not only provides a wealth of on-market listings but also serves as a hub for off-market homes for sale. Investors can leverage CityRealty.com's extensive database to access a wide range of properties that might be private.

For real estate investors in New York, CityRealty.com is a trusted ally, offering a user-friendly interface, in-depth market insights, and the potential to connect with homeowners looking to market off-market properties discreetly; this helps investors stay at the forefront of the off-market real estate scene and secure lucrative deals their less in-tune counterparts don’t know about.

FREE Wholesaling Real Estate and Flipping Houses Training


Alternative Strategies To Find Off-Market Properties In New York

In addition to traditional channels, like those listed above, unconventional methods can successfully unveil hidden off-market properties New York homeowners want to sell. These approaches often revolve around cultivating networks, tapping into personal connections, and harnessing insider knowledge. Consequently, here are two alternative strategies that can help investors find off-market properties in The Empire State:

  • Engaging With Real Estate Agents & Brokers
  • Networking With Other Homebuyers & Investors

Engaging With Real Estate Agents & Brokers

Networking with real estate investors and brokers is a potent strategy for investors looking for exclusive off-market deals in New York. By building relationships within the real estate community, investors gain access to a wealth of insider information and off-market opportunities that may not be publicly advertised. This approach is particularly effective in uncovering off-market properties NYC residents want to sell, as these deals often circulate within professional networks before reaching broader audiences.

The best way for investors to network with real estate agents and brokers involves active participation in industry events, conferences, and local meetups. Attending these gatherings provides a platform for face-to-face interactions, fostering trust and credibility within the real estate community. Interacting with online forums and social media groups specific to the New York real estate market also offers a virtual space for networking, allowing investors to exchange insights, share experiences, and potentially discover off-market homes for sale through referrals or direct connections.

In a city where off-market properties New York residents want to sell are in high demand, cultivating relationships with real estate professionals proves invaluable. By actively participating in both physical and virtual networking opportunities, investors position themselves to access the off-market deals that can change their careers.

Networking With Other Homebuyers & Investors

Networking with homebuyers and investors is a strategic move for investors seeking off-market deals in New York. Establishing connections within these groups opens the door to off-market properties NYC residents want to sell, often before these opportunities reach broader markets.

The best way for investors to network with homeowners and investors is through local community events, real estate seminars, and online platforms specific to New York's real estate scene. Building rapport in these forums allows investors to gain insights, forge connections, and potentially discover off-market homes for sale.

Read Also: 11 Best Platforms For Your Real Estate Social Network


New York MLS Listings Vs. Non-MLS Listings

While the appeal of off-market properties remains strong, especially in competitive markets like New York, it's crucial not to overlook the advantages presented by the Multiple Listing Service.

The MLS is a comprehensive, centralized repository of property listings, making it an indispensable tool for serious real estate investors or homebuyers. Unlike off-market deals, which can be elusive and require extensive networking efforts, MLS listings are readily accessible and user-friendly. This accessibility ensures you don't miss valuable opportunities that might be overlooked in the off-market space.

Furthermore, MLS-listed properties offer the added benefit of being associated with real estate agents. These professionals provide details on the property and market trends, facilitating a transparent and efficient negotiation process; this is particularly advantageous for newcomers or those seeking a more guided approach to property investment.

Investors who exclusively wait for off-market deals risk bypassing many opportunities available through the MLS. MLS listings, ranging from fixer-uppers to turnkey homes, provide a diverse spectrum of investment possibilities in a market like New York's. Additionally, MLS-listed properties adhere to regulatory standards, ensuring transactional transparency and security.

For individuals aiming to maximize their real estate endeavors, Real Estate Skills offers a complimentary training course that goes over accessing the MLS without a license and strategies for wholesaling and house flipping. This course bestows participants with the skills and knowledge to make the most of MLS listings, whether they are seasoned investors or just starting. Explore our free training course today to unlock the potential of the MLS in your real estate ventures.

Read Also: How To Get MLS Access In 6 Ways (Even Without A License)


Pros Of Off-Market Properties

Dealing with off-market properties New York residents intend to sell coincides with several benefits, not the least of which include:

  • Reduced Competition: Off-market properties offer investors a competitive edge by operating outside public listings, reducing the number of potential buyers vying for the same opportunities and increasing the likelihood of securing a desirable deal.
  • Lower Sale Price: Sellers of off-market properties may be more motivated to negotiate favorable terms due to the private nature of the transaction, often resulting in a lower sale price for investors than properties in the public market.
  • Smoother Negotiations: The private nature of off-market deals allows for more direct and focused negotiations between buyers and sellers, fostering a smoother and more personalized process that can cater to both parties' specific needs and goals.
  • Flexible Transaction Timelines: Off-market transactions often afford more flexibility regarding closing timelines, as they are not bound by the same urgency or external pressures typically associated with public listings.
  • Unique Investment Opportunities: Investors gain access to a diverse range of unique and exclusive investment opportunities that may not conform to mainstream market trends.


Cons Of Off-Market Properties

Dealing with off-market properties New York residents intend to sell has its drawbacks. Investors looking for off-market houses for sale should be aware of these cons:

  • Limited Availability: Off-market properties, by their nature, have limited visibility, making it challenging for investors to find a diverse range of options to choose from.
  • Difficulty Finding Properties: Investors face the hurdle of locating off-market properties, as these deals are not publicly listed, requiring extensive networking, research, and effort to uncover opportunities that align with their investment criteria.
  • Challenges With Inexperienced Sellers: Dealing with inexperienced sellers in off-market transactions can present challenges, as these sellers may be less familiar with the intricacies of real estate transactions.


Final Thoughts On Off-Market Properties In New York

The more avenues investors explore to find subject properties, the greater their chances of securing a lucrative deal. While traditional methods and public listings have their merits, exploring the world of off-market deals should be viewed as a complement to a broader acquisition strategy and a powerful tool in its own right. Nonetheless, the reduced competition, unique opportunities, and potential for more personalized negotiations make off-market properties valuable for investors seeking to diversify their portfolios and gain a competitive edge.

Ready to take the leap towards financial freedom and escape the constraints of the antiquated 9-5 routine? Look no further. Contact Real Estate Skills today and unlock the door to a world of opportunities in the real estate industry. Whether you're eager to explore the lucrative field of wholesaling or rehabbing, our comprehensive courses and expert guidance will set you on the path to success.

free real estate investment training

Unlock Our FREE Webinar Training

Founder & CEO of Real Estate Skills, Alex Martinez, reveals the systems and processes used to wholesale and flip houses without doing any marketing!

  • Completely FREE training video.
  • No prior experience is required to start.
  • Begin investing with no cost for marketing.
  • Learn to invest in any real estate market.
  • Discover how you can close deals consistently

Enter your information below to unlock the FREE webinar!

By providing my contact info, I give express written consent to Real Estate Skills to email, call, & send text messages for upcoming events & reminders. By opting in you agree to RealEstateSkills.com's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Reviews & testimonials from students like you.

No matter where you start, you can become a successful real estate investor. Listen to these amazing stories from the students in our program!